Photo of Alan J. Pransky

Experienced Legal Service
for Dedham and the Greater Boston Area

Family Law, Real Estate and Probate Attorney
Photo of Alan J. Pransky

Benjamin Franklin’s Will: The 200-Year Experiment That Ended in Court

by | Nov 12, 2026 | Historic and Famous Wills and the Stories They Tell |

Benjamin Franklin's Will: The 200-Year Experiment That Ended in Court

Benjamin Franklin is remembered as a Founding Father, inventor, diplomat, and scientist. Less well known is that his will established a financial plan intended to operate for 200 years after his death.

Most people preparing a will concern themselves with what will happen to their property after they die. Franklin apparently thought that was insufficient planning. He wanted to know what would happen to his money 200 years later.

Franklin died on April 17, 1790, at age 84. His will, dated July 17, 1788, and a codicil dated June 23, 1789, were admitted to probate in Philadelphia on April 23, 1790.

The codicil established charitable trusts for Boston and Philadelphia. Franklin made detailed projections concerning the growth of both trusts over the following 200 years.

The Boston trust would eventually become the subject of numerous decisions by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

Franklin’s Plan for the Next 200 Years

Franklin left £1,000 sterling each to Boston and Philadelphia. Rather than allowing the cities to spend the money immediately, he directed that it be lent to young tradesmen to help them establish businesses.

The borrowers had to be married, under age 25, and have completed apprenticeships. They also needed two respectable citizens willing to guarantee repayment.

Loans were to range from £15 to £60, with interest at 5% annually. As borrowers repaid their loans, the money would become available to assist others.

Franklin believed that the accumulating interest would cause the funds to grow substantially.

In his codicil, Franklin calculated how much each trust would accumulate after 100 years and again after 200 years.

He projected that after 100 years, each original £1,000 fund would grow to approximately £131,000.

At that point, he directed that £100,000 of the Boston fund be spent on public improvements, including bridges, aqueducts, public buildings, and other projects benefiting the city’s inhabitants.

The remaining £31,000 would continue to accumulate for another 100 years.

Franklin calculated that by the end of the second century, the Boston fund could reach £4,061,000. He directed that £1,061,000 be placed at the disposal of Boston’s inhabitants and £3 million at the disposal of the Massachusetts government.

He made corresponding projections and directions for the Philadelphia trust.

Franklin was an accomplished scientist and inventor, but his projections demonstrate that even Benjamin Franklin could not predict 200 years of investment performance.

Franklin himself recognized that his expectations might be overly optimistic. Near the end of his codicil, he acknowledged:

“I have, perhaps, too much flattered myself with a vain Fancy”

He recognized that unforeseen difficulties might interfere with his plans but expressed confidence that ways could be found to overcome them.

As events would demonstrate, Franklin was correct about the difficulties, although perhaps not about how much litigation would be required to resolve them.

The Rule Against Perpetuities: How Could a Trust Last 200 Years?

Franklin’s plan raises an interesting legal question. How could he establish a trust intended to last 200 years when the law generally restricted the ability of a person to control property long after death?

The Rule Against Perpetuities is a complicated legal doctrine intended to limit how long certain restrictions and conditions imposed by a will or trust can control the future ownership of property.

In simplified terms, the law places limits on how far into the future a person can dictate what must happen to property rather than allowing it to pass to someone who can own it free of those conditions.

At first glance, Franklin’s plan appeared to exceed those limits. He directed that the funds remain under trust administration for 200 years, with substantial distributions postponed until the end of that period.

However, the law recognized an important exception for charitable trusts.

Unlike ordinary private trusts, a valid charitable trust could continue indefinitely without violating the traditional Rule Against Perpetuities merely because of its duration.

In Jackson v. Phillips, 14 Allen 539, 550 (1867), the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court recognized that charitable trusts could be perpetual in duration.

Franklin’s trusts were established for charitable purposes, including assisting young tradesmen and eventually providing money for public improvements and governmental purposes.

Consequently, the planned 200-year duration did not, by itself, invalidate the trusts under the Rule Against Perpetuities.

What Happens When the Trustees No Longer Exist?

Franklin’s will also illustrates another fundamental principle of trust law: a trust does not fail merely because there is no trustee available to administer it.

Franklin directed that Boston’s selectmen, together with ministers of specified churches, manage the trust.

However, Boston became a city in 1822. Its town government was replaced, and the office of selectman ceased to exist.

Franklin had planned for the next 200 years, but apparently had not considered that Boston might change its form of government.

Did that mean the trust could no longer operate?

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court answered that question in City of Boston v. Doyle, 184 Mass. 373 (1903).

The Court held that Boston’s aldermen had not automatically succeeded the selectmen as managers of the trust.

Nevertheless, the disappearance of the designated managers did not invalidate the trust.

The Court directed the appointment of nine lay managers, including Boston’s mayor, to serve with the ministers designated under the codicil.

The decision illustrates the principle that equity will not permit an otherwise valid trust to fail for want of a trustee.

When a trustee dies, resigns, refuses to serve, or otherwise becomes unavailable, a court can appoint a successor when necessary to continue administering the trust.

This principle is now reflected in G.L. c. 203E, § 704, which provides for filling vacancies in trusteeships, including appointment by a court when necessary.

Franklin’s trust survived because the disappearance of its original management structure did not destroy the charitable purposes for which it had been established.

The Lending Program Comes to an End

Franklin’s lending program did not continue for the entire 200 years.

The first loan was made in May 1791. The last loan to a qualifying married apprentice was made around 1886.

Changes in economic conditions and the decline of traditional apprenticeships made it increasingly difficult to continue the program as Franklin had envisioned.

Nevertheless, the trust continued to accumulate money.

Following the first 100-year period, the managers arranged for the distribution of funds for public improvements. In January 1894, approximately $329,300 was paid to Boston’s treasurer.

Those funds, together with subsequent accumulations and a contribution from Andrew Carnegie, helped establish the Franklin Union, a technical school that eventually became the Franklin Institute of Boston.

The institution reflected Franklin’s interest in helping young people acquire useful skills.

Could the Trust Be Terminated Early?

In 1958, the Massachusetts Legislature enacted legislation intended to permit the remaining trust funds to be transferred to the Franklin Foundation for the benefit of the Franklin Technical Institute.

The proposed transfer required authorization from the Supreme Judicial Court.

The Foundation sought that authorization, arguing that the original lending program was no longer practical.

In Franklin Foundation v. Attorney General, 340 Mass. 197 (1960), the Court refused to terminate the trust.

The Court explained that Franklin had intended more than simply making loans to young tradesmen. He had also intended to provide substantial gifts to Boston and Massachusetts at specified future dates.

Even if the original lending program had ceased to serve a useful purpose, that did not justify defeating Franklin’s other charitable objectives.

The Court concluded that the record did not justify terminating the trust before the expiration of its intended term.

Franklin’s instructions would continue to govern.

What Happened When the 200 Years Ended?

The second century of the Boston trust ended on June 30, 1991.

According to the agreed facts reported in subsequent litigation, the remaining trust assets totaled approximately $4.65 million.

Although substantial, the fund had not grown as Franklin originally projected.

A final dispute arose over who was entitled to receive the money.

The Franklin Institute argued that the 1958 legislation should be applied to distribute the funds for its benefit.

Boston and the Commonwealth maintained that the legislation had been intended to terminate the trust early and did not apply after the expiration of the 200-year period.

In Franklin Foundation v. Attorney General, 416 Mass. 483 (1993), the Supreme Judicial Court agreed with Boston and the Commonwealth.

The Court held that the 1958 legislation was intended to authorize early termination, not to alter the distribution when the trust reached the end of its prescribed term.

Consequently, the remaining funds were to be distributed according to Franklin’s codicil rather than the 1958 legislation.

More than two centuries after his death, Franklin’s testamentary instructions remained legally significant.

Franklin’s Legacy in Massachusetts Trust Law

Franklin’s will illustrates several important principles of trust law.

First, charitable trusts are treated differently from ordinary private trusts under the Rule Against Perpetuities.

Second, a trust does not fail merely because its designated trustees are no longer available. Courts can appoint replacements when necessary to carry out the purposes of a valid trust.

Third, the inability to carry out one aspect of a charitable trust does not necessarily require termination of the entire trust. Courts may preserve the trust when other material charitable purposes remain capable of fulfillment.

Franklin could not anticipate changes in municipal government, economic conditions, or lending practices over the following two centuries.

Nevertheless, the Massachusetts courts repeatedly intervened to preserve his charitable objectives.

His financial projections proved overly optimistic, and his original lending program ended long before the trust expired.

Yet his will continued to generate litigation more than 200 years after his death.

Most people hope to be remembered after they die. Benjamin Franklin found an unusual way to ensure that he would be. His will kept his name before the courts and in the news more than two centuries after his death.

In the 1737 edition of Poor Richard’s Almanack, Franklin observed:

“A countryman between 2 Lawyers, is like a fish between two cats.”

The quotation suggests that Franklin did not have a particularly high opinion of lawyers. There is, therefore, considerable irony in the fact that the Boston trust established by his will became the subject of numerous reported Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decisions, with lawyers arguing over its administration, continuation, and eventual distribution.

Franklin’s place in American history was already secure. His will gave him an additional distinction: a permanent place in Massachusetts trust law.

More than two centuries after his death, Benjamin Franklin was still making news, keeping lawyers employed, and giving judges something to write about.

One suspects that Poor Richard would have appreciated the irony.

Sources

Benjamin Franklin’s Will and Codicil

Benjamin Franklin, Last Will and Testament, July 17, 1788, and Codicil, June 23, 1789.

Poor Richard’s Almanack

Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richard’s Almanack (1737).

https://usinfo.org/usia/usinfo.state.gov/usa/infousa/facts/loa/bf1737.htm

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Decisions

Jackson v. Phillips, 14 Allen 539 (1867).

https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/96/96mass539.html

City of Boston v. Doyle, 184 Mass. 373 (1903).

https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/184/184mass373.html

Franklin Foundation v. Attorney General, 340 Mass. 197 (1960).

https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/340/340mass197.html

Franklin Foundation v. Attorney General, 416 Mass. 483 (1993).

https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/416/416mass483.html

Additional Franklin Trust Litigation

Higginson v. Turner, 171 Mass. 586 (1898).

Madden v. Boston, 177 Mass. 350 (1901).

Boston v. Curley, 276 Mass. 549 (1931).

Franklin Foundation v. Boston, 336 Mass. 39 (1957).

Franklin Foundation v. Collector-Treasurer of Boston, 344 Mass. 573 (1962).

Opinion of the Justices, 374 Mass. 843 (1978).

Massachusetts Statute

Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 203E, § 704.

FindLaw | Alan J. Pransky | Rate Us
5 | Five Star Reviews Site | Click Here To Read Our Reviews Or Post A New Review
Avvo | Top Contributor | Family
Avvo | Top Contributor | 2013 | Real Estate
Avvo Rating | Superb | Top Attorney Divorce
Divorce Encyclopedia
DS | Visit Our Page on divorcesource.com
Avvo Rating | 9.2 | Alan J Pransky | Top Attorney
View My Profile on Avvo
2025 | Pro Bono Leader | American Bar Association | Free Legal Answers
REBA Member